21-06-2025

Trump-Newsom Clash Over LA Troop Deployment

Date: 21-06-2025
Sources: bbc.com: 1 | nypost.com: 2 | nytimes.com: 3
Image for cluster 2
Image Source:

Source: nytimes.com

Image content: The black-and-white photo shows a group of people at a public gathering or protest. In the background, a person raises a clenched fist while others look on, and in the foreground a woman with folded arms appears thoughtful or solemn.

Summary

A federal appeals court allowed President Trump to retain control of roughly 4,000 California National Guard troops and 700 Marines deployed around Los Angeles amid protests over immigration enforcement, escalating a high-stakes legal and political battle with Governor Gavin Newsom. The administration argues the forces protect federal personnel and facilities during ICE operations, while California leaders contend the move is unlawful overreach and political theater, saying local authorities maintained order and that federal troops should not police city streets. The Ninth Circuit found Trump likely acted within his authority to federalize the Guard, yet affirmed such actions remain subject to judicial review. The episode has fueled partisan narratives: Republicans framing Democratic governance as ineffective and Democrats accusing the White House of staging a spectacle to bolster law-and-order themes. Further litigation may define the limits of federalized forces’ roles and could reach the Supreme Court.

Key Points

  • Ninth Circuit allowed Trump to keep control of federalized California National Guard, pending further review.
  • California argues overreach and Posse Comitatus concerns; feds say troops protect ICE and federal sites.
  • Political fallout intensifies as Republicans blame Democrats for unrest and Democrats call the deployment a stunt.
  • On-the-ground impact was limited legally and operationally, with troops mostly confined to protection roles.
  • Next steps include potential Ninth Circuit rehearing, Supreme Court appeal, and disputes over troop mission scope.

Articles in this Cluster

US court allows Trump to keep control of National Guard in LABritish Broadcasting CorporationBritish Broadcasting Corporation

A U.S. appeals court ruled that President Trump can retain control of about 4,000 National Guard troops deployed to Los Angeles amid protests over his immigration crackdown, reversing a lower court’s finding that he acted illegally. The panel said Trump was within his authority to federalize the Guard to protect federal personnel and property, even if he didn’t act through the governor. While allowing the deployment to continue, the judges noted Trump’s actions remain subject to judicial review. Governor Gavin Newsom criticized the decision as enabling authoritarian use of the military against citizens. The administration says the troops and additional Marines were sent to safeguard ICE agents and federal sites during raids.
Entities: U.S. appeals court, Donald Trump, National Guard, Los Angeles, Gavin NewsomTone: analyticalSentiment: neutralIntent: inform

Gavin Newsom sipped wine at Napa fundraiser while anti-ICE protesters plunged L.A. into chaos

California Gov. Gavin Newsom attended a June 7 Napa Valley fundraiser at his Odette Estate Winery as anti-ICE protests in Los Angeles escalated into violence, including attacks on police, arson, and graffiti. A witness criticized his casual presence at the “Vineyard Vibes” event, which raised money for the PlumpJack Foundation benefiting UCSF Cancer Center. Later that evening, President Trump deployed the National Guard to LA over Newsom’s objections. The episode revived criticism of Newsom as out of touch, echoing past controversies like his 2020 pandemic-era dinner. Newsom’s office said he proudly attended the charity event in honor of his late mother.
Entities: Gavin Newsom, Los Angeles, ICE, National Guard, Odette Estate WineryTone: analyticalSentiment: negativeIntent: critique

What will it take for Gavin Newsom to focus on his day job?

The op-ed argues that Gov. Gavin Newsom prioritizes national political positioning over governing California, criticizing him for opposing ICE actions, mishandling crises like LA fires, and posturing ahead of 2028. It links rising homelessness, crime, high living costs, and population decline—leading to lost House seats—to his leadership, and urges him to refocus on state issues rather than litigating against federal actions like the National Guard deployment to Los Angeles.
Entities: Gavin Newsom, California, ICE, Los Angeles, National GuardTone: analyticalSentiment: negativeIntent: critique

The Lessons of Trump’s Fight With Los Angeles Over Immigration - The New York Times

The article examines President Trump’s immigration raids in Southern California and the ensuing protests as a deliberate political spectacle designed to project strength and highlight perceived Democratic paralysis. While images of unmarked federal agents, clashes with protesters, and Marines posted in Los Angeles suggested chaos and justified federal intervention, the reality was more limited: most detainees lacked criminal records, disturbances were manageable, and legal constraints kept the National Guard and Marines largely on the sidelines. Governor Newsom called the deployment “Kabuki,” arguing it served Trump’s narrative rather than public safety. The episode underscores a broader strategy for Trump’s second term: use federal crackdowns in Democratic cities to stoke conflict, frame urban unrest as a security crisis, and galvanize supporters around immigration and law-and-order themes.
Entities: Donald Trump, Los Angeles, Southern California, Governor Gavin Newsom, National GuardTone: analyticalSentiment: negativeIntent: analyze

Vance Blames L.A. Violence on California Democrats and Disparages Padilla - The New York Times

Vice President JD Vance, speaking at Los Angeles’s Wilshire Federal Building, criticized California Democrats—Gov. Gavin Newsom, Mayor Karen Bass, and Sen. Alex Padilla—over recent protests and clashes tied to immigration enforcement, calling Democrats’ actions “political theater.” He mistakenly referred to Padilla as “Jose Padilla,” later calling it a misspeak. Newsom challenged Vance to a debate, and Bass accused the Trump administration of staging a “stunt” by deploying thousands of National Guard troops and hundreds of Marines, saying local law enforcement kept order. Padilla, recently handcuffed after interrupting Homeland Security Secretary Kristi Noem, was not arrested and met with Noem afterward. Vance framed Democratic interventions as publicity-seeking; Padilla’s office called the administration “unserious.”
Entities: JD Vance, Gavin Newsom, Karen Bass, Alex Padilla, Kristi NoemTone: analyticalSentiment: negativeIntent: critique

Where Trump and Newsom’s Fight Over the California National Guard Stands - The New York Times

President Trump federalized the California National Guard and sent active-duty Marines to Los Angeles amid protests over ICE raids, overriding Gov. Gavin Newsom’s objections and triggering a major legal fight over presidential authority to deploy troops domestically. California argues the move is an unlawful overreach, that local authorities can manage unrest, and that using federal troops as law enforcement violates the Posse Comitatus Act. The administration says violence around protests impeded immigration enforcement and that troops are protecting ICE, not policing. A federal judge initially ordered the Guard returned to state control, calling Trump’s action improper and not justified by a “rebellion,” and faulted bypassing the governor. The Ninth Circuit stayed and then unanimously extended the block on that order, finding Trump likely acted within his authority and rejecting the bypass argument, while affirming courts can review such presidential determinations. Trump currently retains control of roughly 4,000 Guard troops, with 700 Marines also deployed. Next steps could include California seeking a larger Ninth Circuit rehearing or appealing to the Supreme Court. Separately, the state may press limits on any federalized forces’ roles, arguing they should be confined to protecting federal facilities rather than accompanying ICE in city streets.
Entities: Donald Trump, Gavin Newsom, California National Guard, U.S. Marines, Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE)Tone: analyticalSentiment: neutralIntent: analyze